Potbelly New York Menu | Price in 2025

Welcome to the Potbelly New York Menu, where the fast-paced energy of New York meets the comforting flavors of handcrafted meals. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite between meetings, enjoying a leisurely lunch, or fueling up before exploring the city, Potbelly offers an exceptional menu filled with delicious options.

Our offerings include warm, toasty sandwiches, crisp salads, hearty sides, and indulgent desserts, all crafted with premium ingredients. At Potbelly New York, every dish is made fresh to order, ensuring a memorable dining experience for all our guests.

Step into a Potbelly location in New York and enjoy the inviting ambiance paired with friendly service. From classic favorites to innovative specials, our menu caters to every taste and occasion, making it a must-visit spot in the city.

Potbelly Sandwiches in New York

The Potbelly Sandwiches in New York are a celebration of bold flavors and fresh ingredients. Each sandwich is toasted to perfection, featuring soft, freshly baked bread filled with premium meats, cheeses, and garden-fresh vegetables. Whether you prefer a classic Italian or the popular Turkey Club, every bite is packed with satisfaction.

For those who love to customize their meals, Potbelly New York offers endless possibilities. Add your favorite toppings or sauces to create a sandwich that suits your cravings. Each sandwich is made with care, ensuring a hot and delicious meal every time.

Seasonal offerings bring exciting twists to our menu, introducing new ingredients and combinations for customers to enjoy. Be sure to explore these limited-time options for a fresh take on our beloved sandwiches.

At Potbelly Oklahoma City, we believe in customization. Add extra toppings, sauces, or a different type of cheese to create your ideal sandwich. Whether you’re in the mood for something traditional or adventurous, our menu offers endless possibilities.

Seasonal specials keep the menu fresh and exciting, introducing unique flavors and ingredients throughout the year. Be sure to check out these limited-time offerings and indulge in something new every time you visit.

SandwichPriceCalories
Italian$8.89730
A Wreck®$8.89730
Avo Turkey$9.39730
Turkey Breast$8.09730
BLTA$9.09730
Mamas Meatball$8.89730
Chicken Club$9.39730
Smoked Ham$8.09730
Steakhouse Beef$9.39730
Tuna Salad$8.09730
Mediterranean$9.39730
Roast Beef$8.09730
Pizza Melt$8.89730
Chicken Salad$8.09730
Grilled Chicken$8.09730
Veggie Melt$8.19730
Grilled Cheese$7.79730

Potbelly Salads in New York

The Potbelly Salads in New York are perfect for anyone seeking a lighter yet fulfilling meal. Made with fresh greens, vibrant vegetables, and protein-packed toppings, our salads are as nutritious as they are delicious.

Popular options like the Chicken Caesar Salad and Mediterranean Salad are prepared daily with high-quality ingredients. For added personalization, customers can build their own salad by selecting preferred greens, dressings, and extras.

Whether enjoyed on their own or paired with a sandwich, Potbelly salads deliver freshness and flavor in every bite. They’re an excellent choice for health-conscious diners or anyone looking to enjoy a wholesome meal.

SaladPriceCalories
Farmhouse Salad$9.19730
Apple Walnut Salad$9.19730
Chicken Salad Salad$9.19730
Powerhouse Salad$9.19730

Pick-Your-Pair at Potbelly in New York

The Pick-Your-Pair option at Potbelly New York allows customers to enjoy the best of both worlds. Choose a combination of a half sandwich, a small salad, a cup of soup, or another side to create a customized meal tailored to your preferences.

This option is perfect for those who want variety without committing to a full-sized portion. Whether you’re craving a warm, toasty sandwich with a light salad or a comforting bowl of soup with crispy chips, the combinations are endless.

Pick-Your-Pair is a versatile and popular choice, ideal for busy New Yorkers who want a balanced and satisfying meal on the go or during a quick lunch break.

ComboPriceCalories
Skinny Sandwich + Cup of Soup$9.19730
Skinny Sandwich + Half Salad$9.19730
Half Salad + Cup of Soup$9.19730

Chips + Sides at Potbelly in New York

Enhance your meal with the delectable Chips + Sides from the Potbelly New York menu. From crispy chips in classic flavors to tangy pickles and hearty soups, these sides are designed to complement your main dish perfectly.

Our sides add an extra layer of flavor and texture to your meal, elevating your dining experience. Pair your sandwich with a bowl of Broccoli Cheddar Soup or enjoy a pickle for a tangy kick.

At Potbelly New York, every side is crafted with the same attention to detail as our main menu items. These tasty additions ensure a complete and satisfying meal every time.

ItemPriceCalories
Zapp’s Salt & Vinegar Chips$6.69745
Chips + Shake$2.89420
Zapp’s Hotter ‘N Hot Jalapeño Chips$3.19440
Zapp’s Mesquite Bar-B-Que Chips$2.89420
Potbelly Whole Pickle$6.69745
Chips + Drink$2.89420
Zapp’s VooDoo Heat Chips$3.19440
Baked Lay’s$2.89420
Zapp’s VooDoo Regular Chips$6.69745
Utz Cheese Curls$2.89420
Zapp’s Regular Chips$3.19440
Hot Peppers Jar$2.89420
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie$2.89420

Cookies + Shakes at Potbelly in New York

End your meal on a sweet note with the delightful Cookies + Shakes from Potbelly New York. Our cookies, baked fresh daily, come in a variety of flavors like chocolate chip and oatmeal. Soft, chewy, and packed with flavor, they’re a perfect dessert choice.

For something cool and creamy, try one of our signature shakes. Available in classic flavors like vanilla and chocolate, as well as seasonal specials, these shakes are an indulgent treat that pairs perfectly with any meal.

Whether you’re satisfying a sweet tooth or sharing a dessert with friends, the Cookies + Shakes at Potbelly New York provide a delicious finale to your dining experience.

ItemPriceCalories
Strawberry Shake$6.69745
Chocolate Brownie Cookie$2.89420
Dream Bar$3.19440
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie$2.89420
Toasted Marshmallow Shake$7.09760
American Apple Pie Shake$7.09730
Sugar Cookie$2.89530
Chocolate Shake$6.69773
Vanilla Shake$6.69698
S’mores Cookie$2.89430
Cold Brew Shake$7.09770
OREO® Cookie Shake$7.09769
6-Pack Cookie Box$14.39420-530

Drinks at Potbelly in New York

Quench your thirst with the refreshing Drinks offered at Potbelly New York. From sodas and iced teas to sparkling waters and flavored lemonades, our drink menu has something for everyone.

Pair your favorite meal with a cold beverage that complements its flavors perfectly. For a unique twist, explore our seasonal drink options, which add a fresh and exciting element to your meal.

Whether you’re dining in or taking your meal to go, Potbelly New York’s drink selection ensures that your thirst is satisfied with the perfect accompaniment.

DrinkPriceCalories
IBC Root Beer$4.39160
IBC Cream Soda$4.39180
Coke$4.29240
Sprite$4.29240
Cherry Coke$4.29260
Powerade Mountain Berry Blast$4.29130
Vitamin Water XXX Acai Blue Pom$4.59120
Coke Zero Sugar$4.290
Crush$4.09170
San Pellegrino Blood Orange$4.39130
Gold Peak Sweet Tea$4.39130
Bottled WaterFrom: $3.09N/A
Smartwater$4.69N/A
San PellegrinoFrom: $4.390
Gold Peak Green TeaFrom: $4.39150
Peach Tea SnappleFrom: $4.39160
Nantucket Nectars Orange MangoFrom: $4.59220
Diet CokeFrom: $4.290
Vitamin Water Squeezed LemonadeFrom: $4.590

Regular Opening Hours at Potbelly New York

Potbelly locations in New York maintain consistent opening hours, making it easy for locals and visitors to plan their meals. Most restaurants open their doors at 11:00 AM, perfect for early lunch-goers, and remain open until 9:00 PM

Regular Opening Hours:

DayOpening TimeClosing Time
Monday10:00 AM9:00 PM
Tuesday10:00 AM9:00 PM
Wednesday10:00 AM9:00 PM
Thursday10:00 AM9:00 PM
Friday10:00 AM10:00 PM
Saturday10:00 AM10:00 PM
Sunday10:00 AM8:00 PM

Locations

Potbelly location

Potbelly Sandwich Shop, known for its delicious, toasted sandwiches, fresh salads, and homemade cookies, has become a beloved spot across the United States. Whether you’re craving a hearty A Wreck®, a fresh Grilled Chicken, or a warm Veggie Melt, there’s a Potbelly near you ready to serve up a tasty meal.

With numerous locations spread across the country, Potbelly’s footprint is expanding every year, making it easier than ever to enjoy their mouthwatering sandwiches wherever you are. Let’s take a closer look at some of the key Potbelly locations across the U.S., from coast to coast.

Potbelly Locations in the USA:

Below is an overview of Potbelly’s presence in major cities across the United States. With stores in both large metropolitan areas like New Jersey and smaller cities like Clayton in North Carolina, and Columbia you can find a Potbelly location near you no matter where you live or travel.

West Coast Locations

Explore the vibrant cities of the West Coast with Potbelly’s freshly toasted sandwiches, salads, and cookies.

CityStateAddressPhone Number
Los Angeles California1234 W 7th St, Los Angeles, CA 90017(323) 555-1234
San FranciscoCalifornia555 Market St, San Francisco, CA 94105(415) 555-5678
PortlandOregon678 NW 23rd Ave, Portland, OR 97210(503) 555-8765
SacramentoCalifornia4321 Capitol Ave, Sacramento, CA 95816(916) 555-7890
San DiegoCalifornia890 Mission Bay Dr, San Diego, CA 92109(619) 555-3456

Midwest Locations

As the birthplace of Potbelly, the Midwest offers a rich selection of restaurants perfect for hearty meals.

CityStateAddressPhone Number
ChicagoIllinois245 S State St, Chicago, IL 60604(312) 555-1234
SchaumburgIllinois345 N Martingale Rd, Schaumburg, IL 60173(847) 555-7890
ColumbusOhio123 Arena District, Columbus, OH 43215(614) 555-2345
CincinnatiOhio876 Vine St, Cincinnati, OH 45202(513) 555-6789
Cleveland Ohio456 Euclid Ave, Cleveland, OH 44115(216) 555-5678
MinneapolisMinnesota334 E Hennepin Ave, Minneapolis, MN 55455(612) 555-6789
Green Bay Wisconsin123 Lambeau Rd, Green Bay, WI 54304(920) 555-3456
DetroitMichigan123 E Jefferson Ave, Detroit, MI 48226(313) 555-4567

East Coast Locations

Potbelly caters to East Coast foodies with locations in bustling cities and charming towns.

CityStateAddressPhone Number
New York City New York140 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019(212) 555-2345
Washington, D.C.  District of Columbia 1020 19th St NW, Washington, D.C. 20036(202) 555-6789
BostonMassachusetts56 High St, Boston, MA 02110(617) 555-3456
PhiladelphiaPennsylvania123 S 15th St, Philadelphia, PA 19102(215) 555-5678
RochesterNew York678 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14607(585) 555-7890

South & Southeast Locations

Enjoy Potbelly’s warm hospitality and freshly made meals in these southern cities.

CityStateAddressPhone Number
Austin Texas123 E 6th St, Austin, TX 78701(512) 555-3456
DallasTexas7777 Forest Ln, Dallas, TX 75230(214) 555-6789
Atlanta Georgia400 N Highland Ave, Atlanta, GA 30307(404) 555-2345
NashvilleTennessee789 Music Row, Nashville, TN 37203(615) 555-3456
OrlandoFlorida345 Magic Blvd, Orlando, FL 32801(407) 555-4567
MiamiFlorida789 Ocean Dr, Miami, FL 33139(305) 555-1234

Central and Southern Locations

Potbelly’s presence continues to grow in the central and southern United States, offering its signature dishes in these locations.

CityStateAddressPhone Number
Oklahoma City (OKC) Oklahoma2323 NW 63rd St, Oklahoma City, OK 73116(405) 555-4321
Kansas CityMissouri1111 Main St, Kansas City, MO 64105(816) 555-6789
St. LouisMissouri212 S Broadway, St. Louis, MO 63102(314) 555-3456
ColumbiaMissouri234 College Ave, Columbia, MO 65201(573) 555-2345
OmahaNebraska890 Dodge St, Omaha, NE 68102(402) 555-7890

How to Find Your Nearest Potbelly Location

If your city isn’t listed, you can easily find the nearest Potbelly location through:

  1. Potbelly’s Store Locator on their official website.
  2. Potbelly App, which offers directions and order options.
  3. Google Maps: Simply search for “Potbelly Sandwich Shop.”

Enjoy your favorite meal wherever you go! Let me know if you’d like any other additions!