Potbelly Underground Menu with Price - 2024

The Potbelly Underground Menu is a special lineup of creative, unique sandwiches that go beyond the classic Potbelly offerings. Tailored for adventurous eaters, these sandwiches mix bold flavors, distinct combinations, and mouth-watering ingredients at affordable prices. This exclusive menu highlights sandwiches like “The Lucky 7” and “The Barnyard,” designed to deliver hearty portions and creative twists on favorite deli staples.

Potbelly Underground Menu Overview

The Potbelly Underground Menu is crafted to satisfy adventurous tastes, featuring originals and bold takes on traditional deli sandwiches. This menu invites customers to explore flavors that combine savory meats, cheeses, and classic condiments in imaginative ways. Whether it’s spicy options like the “Fireball” or unique creations like the “Elvis,” there’s something for every palate. Here, we outline the standout selections, nutritional information, and pricing, along with recommended pairings for each sandwich.

Main Potbelly Underground Items Table

Item NameIngredientsCaloriesPrice
Lucky 7A mix of turkey, ham, roast beef, salami, mortadella, capicola, pepperoni836$7.65
Wrecking BallA Wreck with added meatballs and Swiss cheese845$7.65
FireballMeatballs, chili, cheddar cheese, hot peppers717$5.80
ClubbyTurkey, ham, bacon, provolone cheese664$6.25
CheeseburgerMeatballs and cheddar cheese642$5.00
The BarnyardA Wreck, bacon, and meatballs735$7.70
SicilianItalian meats, meatballs, mushrooms, marinara, provolone cheese850$6.25
Black and BleuRoast beef and bleu cheese548$5.00
Chicken Cordon BleuGrilled chicken, smoked ham, Swiss cheese498$6.45
Toasty Turkey BLTTurkey breast and bacon624$6.00
ElvisPeanut butter, bananas, and bacon780$6.10

Potbelly Underground Sandwiches with Prices

Each sandwich, offering background on each unique flavor profile. For example, the “Lucky 7” brings together a mix of meats, while the “Wrecking Ball” adds a rich layer of meatballs and Swiss cheese to the popular “A Wreck” sandwich. With prices ranging from $5.00 to $7.70, these sandwiches cater to all budget levels, ensuring an indulgent yet affordable experience.

Potbelly Underground Sandwiches Table

Sandwich NameDescriptionCaloriesPrice
Lucky 7A signature sandwich combining turkey, ham, roast beef, and Italian meats836$7.65
Wrecking BallAn upgrade to A Wreck, adding meatballs and Swiss cheese845$7.65
FireballSpicy sandwich with meatballs, chili, cheddar cheese, and hot peppers717$5.80
ClubbyA club-style sandwich with turkey, ham, bacon, and provolone cheese664$6.25
CheeseburgerClassic sandwich with meatballs and melted cheddar cheese642$5.00
The BarnyardHearty mix of A Wreck with bacon and meatballs735$7.70
SicilianItalian meats with mushrooms, marinara, and provolone850$6.25
Black and BleuBold roast beef paired with bleu cheese548$5.00
Chicken Cordon BleuGrilled chicken and smoked ham with Swiss cheese498$6.45
Toasty Turkey BLTTurkey breast with crispy bacon624$6.00
ElvisUnique combo of peanut butter, bananas, and bacon780$6.10

Potbelly Underground Sandwich with calories

SandwichKey IngredientsFlavor ProfileCaloriesPrice
Lucky 7Mixed deli meatsSavory & rich836$7.65
Wrecking BallMeatballs, Swiss cheeseBold & cheesy845$7.65
FireballChili, cheddar, hot peppersSpicy & hearty717$5.80
ClubbyTurkey, ham, bacon, provoloneSmoky & satisfying664$6.25
CheeseburgerMeatballs, cheddarClassic & cheesy642$5.00
The BarnyardBacon, meatballsHearty & savory735$7.70
SicilianItalian meats, mushrooms, marinaraItalian & tangy850$6.25
Black and BleuRoast beef, bleu cheeseSharp & bold548$5.00
Chicken Cordon BleuGrilled chicken, smoked ham, SwissMild & savory498$6.45
Toasty Turkey BLTTurkey breast, baconClassic BLT twist624$6.00
ElvisPeanut butter, bananas, baconSweet & savory780$6.10

Potbelly Underground Specialty Items with Prices

In addition to sandwiches, Potbelly’s Underground Menu offers specialty items that elevate the standard deli fare. These items bring unique ingredients and flavorful combinations, from savory club-style sandwiches like “The Barnyard” to the unconventional “Elvis” with peanut butter, bananas, and bacon. Priced between $5.00 and $7.70, these specialty items cater to both classic and experimental taste buds.

 

Potbelly Underground Specialty with Prices

 

Specialty ItemDescriptionCaloriesPrice
Lucky 7Signature mixed deli meats sandwich836$7.65
Wrecking BallMeatball and Swiss cheese combination845$7.65
FireballChili and cheddar-filled spicy option717$5.80
The BarnyardA Wreck with added bacon and meatballs735$7.70
SicilianItalian meats, mushrooms, marinara, provolone850$6.25
Black and BleuRoast beef with bleu cheese for bold flavors548$5.00
ElvisSweet and salty mix with peanut butter, bananas, and bacon780$6.10

 

 

Latest Potbelly Underground Promotions and Deals

Potbelly frequently rolls out limited-time promotions and deals, making it even easier for customers to explore the Underground Menu. This section covers any current deals for 2024, including combo offers, discounts on new items, or special pricing events. Check here for the latest ways to enjoy more of the Underground Menu at an exceptional value.

How to Order Potbelly Underground Menu Online

Ordering from Potbelly’s Underground Menu has never been easier. This guide outlines the steps for online ordering, detailing how to customize sandwiches, add sides, and select beverages. It also covers delivery options and estimated delivery times, ensuring that customers can enjoy their favorite underground creations from the comfort of their homes.

How to Pick Up Your Potbelly Underground Order?

For customers who prefer picking up their order, this section provides a quick guide on how to place a pickup order at Potbelly locations offering the Underground Menu. With instructions on customizing your sandwich, selecting a preferred location, and knowing estimated wait times, this guide ensures a smooth, convenient pickup experience.